Follow up on Jill Greenberg

Regarding the Jill Greenberg controversy

The Atlantic Monthly will send a letter of apology to John McCain, will not pay Greenberg, and is considering legal action against her

What other photo editors think of this stunt? « Jill Greenberg officially took herself off everyone’s list with that little stunt. (…) Even if some Photo Editor wanted to hire her now they wouldn’t get her past the editor let alone the publicist. », says the Photo editor blog

Jeffrey Goldberg, writer for the story on McCain that Greenberg took photos of: « I don’t know Greenberg (I count this as a blessing) and I can add nothing to what James Bennet told the Post except to say that Greenberg is quite obviously an indecent person who should not be working in magazine journalism »

Editor of The Atlantic answers questions from Fox News

Victoriaville Tigre Loic Boivin
Victoriaville Tigre Loic Boivin juggles with the puck in QMJHL action against the Remparts at le Colisee Pepsi in Quebec city. Victoriaville won 4-0.
Technical: Canon EOS Mark III, 1/800 at f3.5 with a 300mm prime lens – ISO 1250

Victoriaville Tigre Maxime Gravel
Victoriaville Tigre Maxime Gravel passes the puck into Quebec Remparts goaltender Charles Lavigne net in QMJHL action at le Colisee Pepsi in Quebec city. Victoriaville won 4-0.
Technical: Canon EOS Mark III, 1/800 at f3.5 with a 300mm prime lens – ISO 1250

As a photojournalist, I photographed every political leader, both on the federal and provincial scenes. 4 parties in Canada, 4 in Quebec, that mean 6 of them where not my guy/girl. But each time, I did my job the best I could, putting aside my political view.

Apparently, not everyone do the same. Jill Greenberg is a top photographer, working with major US publication. How many of us can say they had 15 minutes with US presidential candidate John McCain?

On assignment for Atlantic magazine, she was on assignment for the cover. Interviewed in PDN magazine, Greenberg tells how she feels about McCain and how she duped him.

Greenberg asked McCain to “please come over here” for one more set-up before the 15-minute shoot was over. There, she had a beauty dish with a modeling light set up. “That’s what he thought he was being lit by,” Greenberg says. “But that wasn’t firing.”

What was firing was a strobe positioned below him, which cast the horror movie shadows across his face and on the wall right behind him. “He had no idea he was being lit from below,” Greenberg says. And his handlers didn’t seem to notice it either. “I guess they’re not very sophisticated,” she adds.

And she added insult to injury by putting amongst others those pictures in rotation as a splash screen of her website.

Now, tell me how someone will trust her to take a photo of them? And which magazine will trust her for a job?

I think she somewhat sums it up:

so maybe it was somewhat irresponsible for them [The Atlantic] to hire me.

I was tagging along a Gazette reporter near Thetford Mines. For a full day, we where following Yves Auger, an “apples detective”. Auger travels extensively across the area to finds and documents apples, especially older or unknown varieties. The story was kind of cool, but then it turned VERY cool when he gets us to the Jeanne D’Arc Beaulieu’s field. She’s a pretty old woman, but still working her field and her garden. The place is like a time travel to the beginning of the colony with all those old building and everything. And she talks and talks, and she gesticulates with her hands full of arthritis. I could have stayed for hours!

s-apples-11.jpg
Technical: Canon EOS Mark III, 1/250 at f5 with a 24-70 at 35mm – ISO 250

s-apples-12.jpg
Technical: Canon EOS Mark III, 1/250 at f5 with a 24-70 at 35mm – ISO 250

s-apples-13.jpg
Technical: Canon EOS Mark III, 1/125 at f6.3 with a 24-70 at 55mm – ISO 200

s-apples-14.jpg
Technical: Canon EOS Mark III, 1/250 at f5 with a 24-70 at 35mm – ISO 250

s-apples-15.jpg
Technical: Canon EOS Mark III, 1/160 at f6.3 with a 24-70 at 52mm – ISO 200

Everything shot with a Mark III and a 300mm, 1/800 at f3.6, ISO 1250

remparts-juniors-01.jpg
Quebec Remparts Jonathan Audy-Marchessault celebrates a goal in QMJHL action at the Colisee Pepsi in Quebec city September 12, 2008.The Montreal Junior plays the first game of it’s history. (Photo Francis Vachon/Montreal Gazette)

remparts-juniors-02.jpg
Montreal Junior Louis-Marc Aubry brings Quebec Remparts Sebastien Trudeau down in QMJHL action at the Colisee Pepsi in Quebec city September 12, 2008.The Montreal Junior plays the first game of it’s history. (Photo Francis Vachon/Montreal Gazette)


Copyright © 2023 Francis Vachon.